“THESE DAYS THERE’S TO MANY FIREWORKS… IT POLLUTES, IT FREAKS OUT DOGS, IT SCARES AUTISTIC CHILDREN. I’M NOT A FAN..”
COUNCILOR ROBERT “BOBBY” WILLIAMS
The tradition of fireworks in Keene, particularly during the Swampbats’ annual Independence Eve celebration, faces scrutiny as the City Council’s Planning License and Development (PLD) committee deliberates on its environmental and social implications. Kevin Watterson, President of the Keene Swampbats, sought approval for a fireworks display, leading to a broader discussion among city officials and the community.
While the PLD committee ultimately recommended approving the license for the upcoming fireworks display, the sentiment among council members suggested a shifting perspective, with at least two expressing outright opposition to future fireworks events. Councilor Bobby Williams, self-dubbed “Councilor Grump,” voiced his disapproval, citing concerns over air pollution, distress to dogs, and the impact on autistic children as reasons for his stance. Although Williams conceded to allow one of the Swampbats’ fireworks shows, he opposed additional displays planned by the team.
The debate extended to public opinion, where concerns about the traditional nature and environmental impact of fireworks were raised. One community member criticized fireworks as “outdated” and “old fashioned,” highlighting their environmental footprint and proposing drone shows as a modern, less intrusive alternative. This sentiment found an ally in newcomer Councilor Edward Hass, who humorously acknowledged joining the “stick in the mud bandwagon,” expressing his personal disdain for fireworks due to the disturbance they cause, including to those with early bedtimes, pets, or PTSD. The impact of fireworks on residents with pets or PTSD was also highlighted by Councilor Phil Jones, noting the community feedback he receives.
The discussion of fireworks is not new to Keene, with Alumni Field hosting Independence Eve fireworks displays long before the Swampbats took over the tradition nearly two decades ago, a mantle previously held by the Rotary Club of Keene. Watterson pointed out the significant community engagement the event draws, with approximately 5,000 attendees each year, primarily families, underscoring the celebratory and communal aspects of the occasion.
Despite the reservations voiced by some council members and citizens, the PLD committee’s decision to permit three fireworks shows for the 2024 season, including the cherished Independence Eve celebration, suggests a compromise. However, the emerging debate underscores a broader conversation about balancing tradition with concerns for the environment and public welfare. As Keene navigates these considerations, the future of fireworks in the city remains an open question.
